Halo Reach Beta Forum
  • Subject: The feeling Reach is missing.
Subject: The feeling Reach is missing.

"Q. Is Reach multiplayer going to be kinda like BF:BC2. Like with weapon and specialization sets in the beginning of the game?

A. no, it will be like halo but with loadouts."
-A. by b.net user GodZillla

Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
When I said there are many other people like me, that makes my statement NOT EGOTISTICAL.
Dictionary.com: "2.
given to talking about oneself; vain; boastful; opinionated. " I would definitely say that despite you admitting that you aren't the best of the best, saying that you are among the best at aiming and the best at adapting to a situation is boastful. It doesn't really pertain to the argument, besides proving that you are good enough to understand skill gap, but you've already stated that, so now all you're doing is reinforcing how much better you are than everyone else. That's pretty egotistical.


Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
There are many players in the top 1% like myself. How is saying i'm in the top 1% egotistical? Are you saying that if I told you I was in the bottom 1% I would be egotistical as well?

At what percent do I become an egotistical jerk because of my skill level?
I never stated that stating that you are in the top 1% is egotistical. You are taking a statement which I made earlier, and gave examples for, and explicitly said had no relation to whatever came after, and made a relation to something that came after it. Claiming that you are in the top 1% is not really egotistical, what it is though, is baseless. Where is the proof. Frankly, you've been throwing around the phrase top 99% as if it's fact. Don't make absolutely baseless remarks to further your argument. I know somewhere in your thread you said that even the casuals agree with you. The casuals who will start getting "slaughtered in bewilderment". Somehow I disagree.

To be honest, after all this, I'd be interested to play you in a game of "MLG" H3. I'm tired of the abuse to less skilled players. You know why? I was a scrub once, a total noob, I probably had something like a .25 K/D. But I worked at it, I played Halo a lot. And recently, I switched gamertags, and now, while not being great or anything, I have around a 1.5 K/D. I know what it's like to suck. And, well... it sucks. And those people want the experience of Halo, without the being trampled and abused by jerks. Yes, I think you're a jerk. At first I was willing to give you a chance, after the OP, but you consistently demean lesser players, make baseless statements to further your arguments, and, in a roundabout way, show that you'd have 99% of the population of Halo players have a less enjoyable experience than you. Without even linking your gamertag. If you're a troll, good job, you baited me. But if you are a troll, you're the best troll I've ever seen. I don't think you're a troll. I just think you're a jerk. I won't be responding to any more of your replies, but if anyone agrees with me, you can PM me.

-BCB-

  • 05.20.2010 6:37 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Spartan R41 FanFictions @ Fanfiction.net [http://www.fanfiction.net/u/2007878/Spartan_R41] Halo Fanfictions and more!

^^^
Sheer awesomeness. And from a "better," player too.

  • 05.20.2010 6:52 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: Nemesis87
^^^
Sheer awesomeness. And from a "better," player too.


...not really awesomeness because anyone with an IQ over 7 could already tell he was being egotistical. Also, why bother brining up the fact that he was a better player anyway? It doesn't do the argument any more justice than it did before, because as I said, anyone could tell he was being egotistical.

  • 05.20.2010 6:57 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Spartan R41 FanFictions @ Fanfiction.net [http://www.fanfiction.net/u/2007878/Spartan_R41] Halo Fanfictions and more!

I feel it's "awesome" because it saves face for Pro players, showing that they're not all egotistical win-tips. Like a Senior Class, there are those that remember being "Freshmen," and they recognize that fun is experienced on different levels.

That's why I felt it was awesome.

Now that Legolas has slain the Cave Troll, let's hop back on track as to Halo: Reach feeling like a Halo game. I will attempt to analyze the game's name, via an older post lost upon seas of Rage.
Posted by: Nemesis87
Halo: Reach
This indicates the storyline; the UNSC's struggle with the Covenant. Gameplay has no realm here, as there are many "Halo" products out there that continue the storyline, yet have no relation to the gameplay of Halo. Novels, action figures, short films and animated films. This is the universe and canon of Halo.
Halo: Reach
This is where the gameplay comes in. Halo Wars, Halo: Combat Evolved, Halo 2, Halo 3: ODST and Halo 3 all had different gameplay mechanics introduced. There are similarities, and then there are stark differences. Reach is a different game. What if Reach were a Squad-Based Tactical Shooter? Just because Reach is an FPS doesn't mean that it must operate identical to previous titles.


[Edited on 05.20.2010 7:12 PM PDT]

  • 05.20.2010 6:59 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Okay.

First of all.

I dont care if you think I am a jerk.

How nice I am does not affect the credibility of my argument.

Top 99%. Me. Fact. Get it?

I am BETTER at getting kills than 99%.

EASILY.

Having 1 50 in H3 puts you in the top 99.9%. I have multiple 50's. Where does that put me.

Top 99% is an UNDER-estimate. Just to be safe.

I dont care if you think I am a jerk, or even if you think I hate casuals.

The sad part is that I wasnt trying to make myself look like I am good at halo to people on the internet.

I was simply explaining why lesser skilled players will likely not notice a slower paced game.

Do you people not get it?

NOT EVERYONE IS THE SAME SKILL.

GET OVER IT.

In H2 if it was lvl50 vs lvl 10, the level 10 would get slaughtered. In H:Reach, the level 10 would just armor lock.

Your whole defense is based on lesser players getting slaughtered.

But we have true skill.

Jesus.

If I wanted to play a game where my actions didnt determine what happened or the outcomes I would go play slots.

If one person does something better than another, the results should be different. The person who does these things better, should win or be given an advantage.

This is not the case in Reach.

The player who moves about the map skillfully gets killed by the kid crouching in the corner (which takes no movement skill).

The player who times his shots gets killed by the player who spamms.

The player who strafes and hits all of his shots gets a mutual kill with the person who didnt strafe, because strafing is so slow in this game.






These are the points you should be arguing. Not whether or not my argument is credible because I think and actually am better at the game than you are.

  • 05.20.2010 7:03 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Spartan R41 FanFictions @ Fanfiction.net [http://www.fanfiction.net/u/2007878/Spartan_R41] Halo Fanfictions and more!

-blam!-, they had another Cave Troll.
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
Okay.
First of all.
I dont care if you think I am a jerk.

Duly noted.
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
How nice I am does not affect the credibility of my argument.
Top 99%. Me. Fact. Get it?
I am BETTER at getting kills than 99%.
EASILY.
Having 1 50 in H3 puts you in the top 99.9%. I have multiple 50's. Where does that put me.

And your proof of this is.... where?
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
The sad part is that I wasnt trying to make myself look like I am good at halo to people on the internet.

... *takes a look at previous posts* GOOD JOB.
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
I was simply explaining why lesser skilled players will likely not notice a slower paced game.

Oh, no we realized it. It may shock you that some of us prefer that as a new twist.
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
In H2 if it was lvl50 vs lvl 10, the level 10 would get slaughtered. In H:Reach, the level 10 would just armor lock.

Unless the Lvl 10 was in fact a theoretical lvl 60 on their first few games.
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
The player who moves about the map skillfully gets killed by the kid crouching in the corner (which takes no movement skill).

As has happened with every FPS in history.
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
The player who times his shots gets killed by the player who spamms.

Not so, in fact I find it to be the opposite, if they're not point blank. If the entire reticule, bloom and all, is covering the target, guess where the bullets are going to go?
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
These are the points you should be arguing. Not whether or not my argument is credible because I think and actually am better at the game than you are.

All of your points are perceptions weighed against previous titles. They are also perceptions in an incomplete BETA. Your arguments aren't "credible" because you project yourself as something without proof, you demean those with different opinions, and your solution seems to be - to all observable evidence - Halo 2 v2.

  • 05.20.2010 7:11 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

OP is 100% right. every fanboy here sucks at halo, and needs to get off of bungies dong

  • 05.20.2010 7:16 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

I understand what you are saying,but my problem with it is the fact that you're not looking at this from a marketing standpoint. You may be in the top 1% of all players, but you have to look at it from the other 99%'s point of view. This is a mass marketed game, with a well recognized name. They aren't trying to please you or the top 5% for that matter. Their aim is to please the "Casual" gamer, the group in the middle, from 25% to 75%. Yes, this new game may be absolutely terrible to you, but for me, in the middle 50%, i thoroughly enjoyed the beta. Plus, last time i checked you can still play H2.

  • 05.20.2010 7:18 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Spartan R41 FanFictions @ Fanfiction.net [http://www.fanfiction.net/u/2007878/Spartan_R41] Halo Fanfictions and more!

Posted by: Khazidhea
OP is 100% right. every fanboy here sucks at halo, and needs to get off of bungies dong

Well, that was sheer knowledge brought down on wings of golden dragons.

Because abusing the game developers and saying "Listen here, motehrf***er, this is how it should be done!" it totally the way to get the point across.

  • 05.20.2010 7:20 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: Nemesis87
Posted by: Khazidhea
OP is 100% right. every fanboy here sucks at halo, and needs to get off of bungies dong

Well, that was sheer knowledge brought down on wings of golden dragons.

Because abusing the game developers and saying "Listen here, motehrf***er, this is how it should be done!" it totally the way to get the point across.

yep. some people are just too hard-headed to figure things out

  • 05.20.2010 7:24 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

I completely agree. 100%

I fooled myself into thinking I loved this game - I did not. Bungie has a lot to fix...And I hope to god that they do, I love Halo, and this isn't the definitive Halo experience.

  • 05.20.2010 7:29 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

If you're truly so much better than the person with armor lock, you should be able to kill them anyway.

Trueskill wasn't always reliable, I would sometimes get paired up with people who would anihilate me with the BR, other times I would get paired up with someone who couln't hit the broadside of a barn with it.

If strafing doesn't work, then stop doing it. I hear crouching reduces reticle bloom, and I still havent experienced the people who could spam the trigger and hit me just as efficiently at long range, perhaps at medium range where the rounds don't spread as much anyway.

Yes this does encourage camping more, but it's a more realistice style of gameplay. Yes, we are supersoldiers, but even the SPARTANS were trained not to rely solely on their superior tech, they recognize that they still die if they get hit with enough bullets and we should as well.

Yes Reach has a slower style of gameplay, but I don't realy see why that's such a huge problem.

I guess I just have inferior thought-process, right? Sorry for not having the required hand-eye coordination to land every single BR round in my opponents face, but there are different styles of skill than precision fire, and what Reach does is it expands the variety of playstyle. Not only the marksman wins, if someone uses sprint and cover well enough, they can close the distance on the sniper and take them down in CQC. In medium rnage, the exact weapon used and the way it is used determines the victor; if it is AR vs plasma repeater, the AR guy will be smart and keep more range while the Plasma repeater guy closes in for a more effective shot.

Reach has many small differences and variable in it as well, and while I don't truly remember my few H2 days, I definately appreciate Reach more than H3 because of its variety.

Sorry if not enjoying getting killed in 4 shots by the BR makes me a noob.

  • 05.20.2010 7:32 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: TLau3789
Plus, last time i checked you can still play H2.


Yeah, over LAN or lolXBC.

If they released Halo 2 for XBL Arcade and I could just go play that, I sure wouldn't be on these forums because I'd be too busy playing it...

  • 05.20.2010 7:55 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: M0 Murder0

If they released Halo 2 for XBL Arcade and I could just go play that, I sure wouldn't be on these forums because I'd be too busy playing it...


Agreed

  • 05.20.2010 7:58 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Posted by: Unit F10
If you're truly so much better than the person with armor lock, you should be able to kill them anyway.

Trueskill wasn't always reliable, I would sometimes get paired up with people who would anihilate me with the BR, other times I would get paired up with someone who couln't hit the broadside of a barn with it.

If strafing doesn't work, then stop doing it. I hear crouching reduces reticle bloom, and I still havent experienced the people who could spam the trigger and hit me just as efficiently at long range, perhaps at medium range where the rounds don't spread as much anyway.

Yes this does encourage camping more, but it's a more realistice style of gameplay. Yes, we are supersoldiers, but even the SPARTANS were trained not to rely solely on their superior tech, they recognize that they still die if they get hit with enough bullets and we should as well.

Yes Reach has a slower style of gameplay, but I don't realy see why that's such a huge problem.

I guess I just have inferior thought-process, right? Sorry for not having the required hand-eye coordination to land every single BR round in my opponents face, but there are different styles of skill than precision fire, and what Reach does is it expands the variety of playstyle. Not only the marksman wins, if someone uses sprint and cover well enough, they can close the distance on the sniper and take them down in CQC. In medium rnage, the exact weapon used and the way it is used determines the victor; if it is AR vs plasma repeater, the AR guy will be smart and keep more range while the Plasma repeater guy closes in for a more effective shot.

Reach has many small differences and variable in it as well, and while I don't truly remember my few H2 days, I definately appreciate Reach more than H3 because of its variety.

Sorry if not enjoying getting killed in 4 shots by the BR makes me a noob.


True skill is reliable enough for you to not be able to make the skill gap out as an excuse for dumbing down the game.

I did stop strafing. But then the skill gap is gone, and I the fact that I have better aim and strafe is now irrelevant. THATS RETARDED.

THIS IS A FPS. AIM SHOULD BE RELEVANT.

Halo was good, special, because it wasnt realistic. Because it DIDNT promote camping and slow gameplay.

They should have SPED UP gameplay for reach, not slowed it down.

Of course there are different styles of skill. They should all be relevant. They have always been relevant. Now they arent.

http://www.bungie.net/Forums/posts.aspx?postID=44387207&v iewreplies=true#end

See?

Argue that.

It is safe to say I know a fair bit more about the balance than you do buddy.

And people armor lock, and then thier friend comes in, then I armor lock, and my friend comes in. Thats stale gameplay and it isnt fun.

Everyone shouldnt be handed a "delay death for 7 seconds" card upon spawning.

It is one thing to have AA as a pickup that 1 player can equip per map, that you can pick up off of someones body when you kill them, but giving it to everyone just makes for stale gameplay.

  • 05.20.2010 9:30 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: DONU7
  • user homepage:

Posted by:xTCx Reloaded
Im pretty sure i could have read The Bible faster than all of those posts.

Greatest H3 Match EVER

And as always, it's high time for the thread to go on its course. I don't see why there's so many people who attack posters. I vote for a new forum system where it uses Youtube's style of comments. You can just "like" someone's damned post instead of posting "agree/disgree" and also add GameFaq's style of muting users so I could just mute a -blam!--load of people who are not contributing to the thread, the forum, or the game at all.

Anyways, on-topic:

If a bunch of you guys want to keep arguing about the integrity of the poster, I'll make you all some damn threads to do it in. I suggest we get back to arguing the fine points of why actually changing Reach to a positive experience is a good thing. Honestly, Reach by itself is ok. It's a good enough game to get by. But just like if this was my own child I say: I know the potential Bungie has, and seeing Bungie take the steps to rather degrade itself and not reach any point near its potential is disheartening.
My short and sweet idea of how Reach would be better:
Keep kill-times the same. Make battles actually happen. None of this "grenade x2, run in, shoot, run out". Encourage people to do something other than run in and melee, or throw grenades like a bish. I play Halo for its direct combat. With ****ing GUNS. I'm not about fighting around corners with wide range explosions. I'm all up for precision. So as far as Reach goes, I have to say this, instead of going to Halo 3's bland and absolutely crappy melee system, I suggest we go to either Halo 2's system, or Shadowrun's system (which means no real melee system. When you do melee it takes at least 3 to kill).

  • 05.20.2010 10:44 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

The thing with almost everyone of the players that dislike Reach, is that you're not opening up to Reach. It has so much more potential than any other game Bungie has made, and maybe even all video games. Just think of all the things Bungie can do with Reach, but no, you want the same thing as you've had for years.

  • 05.20.2010 10:58 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Spartan R41 FanFictions @ Fanfiction.net [http://www.fanfiction.net/u/2007878/Spartan_R41] Halo Fanfictions and more!

Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
It is safe to say I know a fair bit more about the balance than you do buddy.

Then enlighten us here, WSJF. Since you're obviously addressing the 99% lesser community, lay it out for us in lay-man's terms.

What's balance?

  • 05.20.2010 11:02 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

If you totally believe in everything you are saying then tell us why you hate reach, because so far you have not given us many reasons.

  • 05.20.2010 11:05 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

No.

Reach Sucks. I am glad the Beta is over. So glad.

I barely played it anyway, and for someone who can reach unimaginable levels of hype, me not playing a Beta for my faviorite game series shows something.

  • 05.20.2010 11:06 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Posted by: SoapyKnight
If you totally believe in everything you are saying then tell us why you hate reach, because so far you have not given us many reasons.


Did I ever say reach sucks?

No.

Seriously kids. If you are 12 then just GTFO. This thread isnt for you.

Learn to read before you use the internet.

  • 05.20.2010 11:17 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Posted by: Nemesis87
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd
It is safe to say I know a fair bit more about the balance than you do buddy.

Then enlighten us here, WSJF. Since you're obviously addressing the 99% lesser community, lay it out for us in lay-man's terms.

What's balance?


Scoll up a little....

see that link!!!!!

OMG!!!! HOW DID THAT GET THERE!!!!!

  • 05.20.2010 11:17 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Spartan R41 FanFictions @ Fanfiction.net [http://www.fanfiction.net/u/2007878/Spartan_R41] Halo Fanfictions and more!

Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd

Must be nice having everyone do work for you.
So pretty much;
-Remove or heavily remake the reticule bloom
-Remove or heavily limit Armor Abilities
-Remove non-regenerative (even though you regenerate three bars) health and the need for healthpacks
-Increase Movement Speed
-Increase Jump Height

Did I miss anything?

Question: What the hell is "Enhanced Radar?" You failed to explain that little nugget.

  • 05.20.2010 11:35 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas

Posted by: TLau3789
I understand what you are saying,but my problem with it is the fact that you're not looking at this from a marketing standpoint. You may be in the top 1% of all players, but you have to look at it from the other 99%'s point of view. This is a mass marketed game, with a well recognized name. They aren't trying to please you or the top 5% for that matter. Their aim is to please the "Casual" gamer, the group in the middle, from 25% to 75%. Yes, this new game may be absolutely terrible to you, but for me, in the middle 50%, i thoroughly enjoyed the beta. Plus, last time i checked you can still play H2.

Actually, you can't play H2 on XBL or any original xbox games anymore. Also, Halo 2 had a large skill gap and casual players still loved it. People keep pointing out H2 because skilled players and "casual" players both enjoyed it.

  • 05.20.2010 11:40 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas
  • gamertag: [none]
  • user homepage:

Posted by: Nemesis87
Posted by: WSJFGBSJLFGBvdjd

Must be nice having everyone do work for you.
So pretty much;
-Remove or heavily remake the reticule bloom
-Remove or heavily limit Armor Abilities
-Remove non-regenerative (even though you regenerate three bars) health and the need for healthpacks
-Increase Movement Speed
-Increase Jump Height

Did I miss anything?

Question: What the hell is "Enhanced Radar?" You failed to explain that little nugget.


No, I did the work for everyone.

Instead of digging through hundereds of threads, I linked the best of the very best, right here.

Lol you dont know what enhanced radar is because you dont play very much H3.

Enhanced radar is a setting in H3 so that when you crouch you still show up on radar.

Personally, I think that the motion sensor is silly past level 35 in MM, because it is just a crutch.

Crutches, bloom, AA, etc is FINE and GOOD for casual gameplay, but their MUST be a way to turn it off as it absolutely RUINS competitive gameplay.

When I searched 4's with my MLG team in reach (all onyx class), literally every game we played on sword base ended up turning into a huge stale mate, because it is soooooo easy to set up on that map and movement speeds are so slow you could not approach your enemy without exposing yourself on a bridge and getting spanked by nade-shot.

You people really dont understand. Good players lock maps like this down.

Like THEY LOCK THAT -blam!- DOWN.

You cant just run across a bridge and not get team-shotted.

The game literally devolves into every single move a player makes being based on spawning of power weapons. The game becomes a game of chess.

H2 had emphasis on power weapons but gameplay never came to a halt like it does consistently in competitive matches of reach.

[Edited on 05.20.2010 11:50 PM PDT]

  • 05.20.2010 11:49 PM PDT
  • reply edit unleash ninjas